Student voice is one of those ideas almost nobody argues against. Of course we should ask students what they think of their learning. Of course their experience matters. Most schools now run some form of student survey at the end of a unit, a semester or a course, and the results feed into reflection, appraisal or departmental review.

I’m in favour of it in principle. But I’ve started to question what those surveys actually measure in a school where grades matter as much as they do.

In a high-pressure, results-driven environment, students are rarely answering the question we think we’re asking. When a survey asks “Did this course help you learn?”, many are really answering “Is this course helping me get the grade I need?” Those are not the same question. A teacher who drills tightly to the exam, hands out model answers and keeps everything predictable may score very well. A teacher who asks students to wrestle with ideas, tolerate uncertainty and think for themselves may score less well, at least in the short term, even if the learning runs deeper.

Research on student evaluations of teaching, mostly from universities, should make us cautious. Ratings can be swayed by expected grades, workload and subject difficulty, and their link to how much students actually learn is far weaker than we tend to assume.

Then there’s the game. Students in competitive schools are sophisticated. Some tell you what they think you want to hear, especially if they’re not fully convinced the survey is anonymous. Some use it to push back against work they find hard. Many simply click through because it’s the fourth survey of the term. None of this makes them bad students. It makes them rational ones.

So are these surveys valid at all, or are we all just playing the game? I think the honest answer is that they’re valid for some things and not for others.

They’re reasonably good at surfacing things students experience directly: unclear instructions, feedback that arrives too late to use, a classroom where some students don’t feel able to speak. They’re much weaker as a measure of teaching quality or depth of learning, and they become actively unhelpful when the results are used to judge teachers without context.

If I were designing a student survey for a grade-hungry school, I’d want to:

  • Ask about specific, observable experiences rather than overall satisfaction
  • Separate questions about learning from questions about enjoyment
  • Treat the results as the start of a conversation with students, not a score
  • Never use them on their own for teacher appraisal
  • Tell students what changed as a result, so the next survey means something

That last one matters most. Students stop taking surveys seriously when nothing visibly happens afterwards. Close the loop, and the answers start to get more honest.

Student voice matters. But if the only questions we ask are shaped by grades, we shouldn’t be surprised when it answers in grades.

Journeying:


Discover more from The Assistant Principal

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

More articles

All articles →

Get the daily post by email

One short idea for school leaders, three mornings a week. Free.