Every school I’ve worked in has had some version of the data project. A spreadsheet, a dashboard, a tracking system, a cycle of entering grades at set points in the year so that someone, somewhere, can see progress. The intention is almost always good. Schools should know how their students are doing, and leaders should be able to spot patterns before they become problems.

But I’ve started to wonder how many of these projects still do what they were designed to do, and how many have simply become compliance.

You can usually tell the difference with one question: what changed because of this data? Not what was reported. What changed. Which student got different support, which unit was redesigned, which conversation happened that otherwise wouldn’t have?

If the honest answer is “not much”, the data project has become a ritual. Teachers enter numbers because the deadline says so. Middle leaders chase the missing cells. Someone produces a summary. The summary goes to a meeting, the meeting moves on, and the cycle starts again. Everyone is busy, and very little is learned.

I’ve now seen this from both sides: asking for the data as a leader, and providing it as a teacher. From the leadership side it can feel like rigour. From the classroom it can feel like feeding a machine that never feeds you back.

Part of the problem is that data has become easier to collect than to use. Modern platforms make it effortless to add another column or another colour-coded chart. What hasn’t become easier is the thinking: sitting with the information, asking what it means, and deciding what to do differently. That takes time, and time is the one thing schools never have spare.

The other problem is that grades are a blunt instrument. A predicted grade tells you very little about why a student is struggling. It doesn’t tell you whether they’ve misunderstood a key concept, lost confidence, or are juggling something at home. The teacher often knows those things. The spreadsheet rarely does.

So are data projects obsolete? I don’t think so. But many of them need to be smaller, sharper and more honest about their purpose. A few questions I’d want any school to ask:

  • What decision will this data inform, and who makes it?
  • How much could we stop collecting without losing anything?
  • Does the data come back to teachers in a useful form, or does it only travel upwards?
  • Are we combining the numbers with the professional knowledge of the people who teach these students?

The most useful data work is usually the least glamorous: a small group of teachers looking at a handful of students together and asking what they know and what they’ll try next. No dashboard required.

Data should start a conversation. When it replaces one, it has stopped being insight and started being compliance.

Journeying:


Discover more from The Assistant Principal

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

More articles

All articles →

Get the daily post by email

One short idea for school leaders, three mornings a week. Free.